I don't see how he screwed it up so badly. He talked about it for weeks on the show. Even I could have thrown better then that on my worst day. I guess that's why he's Ta-Ta-Toothy.
I would have thought that a pitch (throw) like that was impossible...
Unless he suffers a serious handicap...He's got to be a "super-spaz" Probably has other difficulties too: Walking and chewing gum Tying shoe laces Distinguishing left from right