I agree with Mike that your usage seems high. In addition to the timer/feed/air settings, can you see what the pressuretrol is set at? Are the steam pipes insulated? Does your boiler run a long time trying to produce steam?I've got a 3700 sq. foot Victorian in central MA, Steam heat, insulated walls, old windows with new Harvey storms, unheated basement, steam heat with complementary furnace on heat exchanger. Keep the thermostat at 68 to keep Mom warm. Before the walls were insulated, I used 15 tons a year. After the walls were insulated...15 tons a year. Tall chimney (3 story house, including attic). This year's spring/summer projects are clearly to focus on windows, doors and more attic insulation...
-Rob