I finally decided to have our chimney cleaned...the last of the creosote is officially gone. To my knowledge this is the first time the chimney had been cleaned in 30 years; previously it served a wood boiler. Due to the unusual construction, the only way to brush this flue is from the top...32 feet up. The stuff that came out of it was NASTY. Black powdery soot that reeked like creosote. With the 2 gallons or so of "sweepings" from today's cleaning, I have collected about 10 gallons of debris from the clean-out of this chimney since I started burning coal.
I fired the EFM back up about an hour ago, and so far the draft control seems noticeably more "active". There is an offset in the chimney, and I suspected that old creosote had fallen off the flue tiles and collected at this offset. The man that did the sweeping said it looked very clean from the top down, so I'm thinking most of the debris came from the offset tiles.
Lesson of the day - If you have a chimney that previously served a wood burning appliance, it is a good idea to have it cleaned before or shortly after you switch to coal. If the buildup is especially bad it can peel off in chunks/sheets and cause an restriction.
One of them Westinghouse light bulbs would be nice too.