Constitution doesn't give SC power to arbitrate Constitution

Forum rules
As the title "Thoughtful and Intelligent Debates" implies we want quality discussion in this forum. If you're going to post a new topic or reply to one here please make sure it fits the following guidelines.

  • Clear and descriptive title for your topic.
  • You don't need to write a book but please have a reasonable amount of material to support or dispute what you are discussing.
  • Outside references to material to support or dispute your argument can be used but they should not wholly make up your argument. If for example you reference a news article please explain exactly what you are referencing and why.
  • Stay on topic, while topics will wander in the general forums we want to keep them strictly on topic in this forum. Flaming will not be tolerated at all.

Constitution doesn't give SC power to arbitrate Constitution

PostBy: lsayre On: Sat Jul 27, 2013 5:28 pm

Check out this absolutely amazing 1820 letter from Thomas Jefferson. He clearly reminds us therein (in this his letter of response) that the Constitution does not grant the Supreme Court the power to arbitrate Constitutional matters. He concisely states why as well, stating that it would lead to despotism.

This power seems to be one of the SCOTUS' most highly regarded functions today. Amazing how things change!!!

http://www.thefederalistpapers.org/foun ... -oligarchy
lsayre
 
Stoker Coal Boiler: AHS S130 Coal Gun
Coal Size/Type: Anthracite Pea
Other Heating: Resistance Boiler (It has been fixed!)

Re: Constitution doesn't give SC power to arbitrate Constitution

PostBy: jpete On: Sat Jul 27, 2013 6:05 pm

It was Marbury v Madison that cemented the philosophy of "judicial review".

Imagine that! The SCOTUS deciding on a case which gave the SCOTUS more power and prestige! Whoda thunk!

TJ was a little late to the party on his opinion. And I believe he and Madison probably knew more about Constitutionality than most since they were two prime movers in it's creation.

But, since Justice Marshall was a Federalist, it's probably no surprise he ruled as he did.
jpete
 
Hand Fed Coal Stove: Harman Mk II
Coal Size/Type: Stove, Nut, Pea
Other Heating: Dino juice

Re: Constitution doesn't give SC power to arbitrate Constitution

PostBy: lsayre On: Sat Jul 27, 2013 7:50 pm

Check out the last line also, wherein Jefferson states that due to the separation of powers the power to legislate is not a function of the Executive branch. Bye-Bye Executive Orders. Despotism is the consequence for these as well.
lsayre
 
Stoker Coal Boiler: AHS S130 Coal Gun
Coal Size/Type: Anthracite Pea
Other Heating: Resistance Boiler (It has been fixed!)