2 or 3 years ago i got 5 ton of the coal from Coal Contractors. Yeah , they charged me a bit more to drive it out this far from Hazelton but it was a nice shiny coal, not dull at all. Burned great, sized very consistent ,lot lower ash than the stuff from new Superior at the time which was surface mined and had the light fluffy ash. I'm sure it varies year to year. Was it worth the extra per ton? I don't know, i don't burn Blaschak. Have a guy at work who says he will never burn Casey Kassa again once he found this coal from the Hazelton area. To me, Blaschak is for people who want bagged and have no other choices. If they both about about the same for you, go with the lower priced one. PM me if you want a drivers phone# who delivers out of Coal Contractors, he may be cheaper than what you pay for bulk if you're not too far away.
Edit, see you are up in NY, most drivers from near the breakers won't go that far, good luck.