Bringing this topic up around NEPA natives can start WW3.
There is lot of Pizza places in Old Forge, actually a lot of pizza places in the Wyoming Valley. One place has been making it since the 20's or 30's.
Lots of varieties in Old Forge as there is in the Wyoming Valley. You could eat pizza for months here and have slightly different variety every day. Old Forge style is typically medium sized crust, slightly fried bottom and topped with different cheese blends. It's good but I don't find it particularly good. Tastes vary of course, it may not be the best pizza for some but undoubtedly they have one of if not the highest concentrations of pizza places considering the population.
I prefer Victory Pig which is super greasy goodness or thin round pie with the cheese swimming in sauce.
Victory Pig can be shipped frozen. It's expensive even if you buy it fresh. http://www.victorypigpizza.com/