All the stoves mentioned are quality built...so you look over the stoves and see what your needs are.....
I think that about sums it, brand name stoves like Keystoker, Alaska Leisure Line
(figured I throw that in there for Leisure Line) are all going to get good reviews by there users. Especially considering many are not going to have anything to compare it to.
They are all well built american products, that's what your paying for. I realy don't think I've heard anyone say they didn't like there stove. You have to figure out what is right for you...
The only thing I will add is make sure you get a big enough one, don't make the mistake of getting one smaller than what you need. Many will buy a small stove thinking they'll just use it and supplementary heat and wish they had purchased a larger unit by the end of there first heating season to heat the whole house. The extra thousand (or whatever it is) is worth the investment.
Personally when buying products I always get a little better than what I need at the moment. Too many times in the past I ended up wishing I had splurged a little bit extra.... not anymore.